How Flamel rates a claim: the three cranes
Every rating on Flamel comes from the same five steps and the same five questions, checked by a person and never for sale. Here is what the cranes mean, and how to borrow the checklist yourself.
Checked against the sources ยท Updated 17 Nov 2026
In short
- Flamel's rating is a public method, not a health result
- This page explains how Flamel rates claims. It is not itself a health claim, so it does not carry cranes. That is different from Not rated yet, which means a health claim we have not checked.
How Flamel rates a claim: the three cranes
A video lands in the family group chat. Someone swears a drink fixed their sleep, their joints, their everything. Then you get tagged, because you are the one everyone asks: is this legit?
That question is why Flamel exists, and here is the working. Every rating comes from the same five steps, for every topic, popular or not, and a person makes the final call. What you see on a rated claim is one of four words and up to three cranes, with the sources beside them.
We rate the claim, not the topic
"Creatine" is not a claim. "Creatine for strength in adults who lift" is. One is a whole topic, with studies pointing in different directions. The other is narrow enough to check. When a claim carries cranes, those cranes belong to that wording. They say nothing about the topic next door.
The five steps
Find. Weigh. Check. Show. Update.
Find. We gather sources, strongest first: official clinical guidelines and large reviews that pool many studies, then trials in people, then studies that watch people over time, then lab and animal work. A lab result is a clue, not proof on its own. Testimonials, ads, and forum posts never count, however many there are.
Weigh. The same five questions for every claim. Was it tested in people? How many studies, and how big? Do the results agree? Is the effect big enough to matter? Who paid? A claim does not earn cranes because it is popular, or because the seller seems kind. It earns them because the answers hold up.
Check. AI may help draft the writing and find sources. A person on the team checks every citation against its source before anything goes live. AI does not set a rating.
Show. The rating, the sources, who checked it, and when sit on the claim. Nothing important is hidden.
Update. Every claim is checked again at least once a year, or sooner when new research lands. A reader, a doctor, or a brand we cover can challenge a rating. Brands named on a claim get a right of reply.
What the four words mean
Clear evidence means the evidence supports the claim and several good studies agree.
Some evidence means it works for some people, some of the time, or the studies are small. Promising, not settled.
Red flag means there is no good evidence for the claim, the evidence goes against it, or the risk outweighs it.
Not rated yet means we have not checked that claim. It is not a guess, and it is not a quiet red flag. The work has not been done.
Some claims carry no cranes on purpose. A how-to, a checklist, or an explanation of a method is not a health claim, so it gets no rating word. That is different from Not rated yet, which belongs to a real claim we have not checked.
Two other labels carry no cranes. Prescription only means registration status first, then a doctor. Not registered in the Philippines means we say what the product is and stop. A claim can also carry a separate line such as "Long practiced in Japan." Tradition is respected. It does not earn cranes by itself.
Where the five questions come from
We did not invent the weigh step. It sits beside the way careful reviewers already judge a question: they rate the whole set of studies, not each paper as a trophy. Studies in which people are assigned by chance to a treatment or a comparison start higher. Certainty drops when the studies were run in a biased way, when the results disagree, when the studies do not match the question, when the estimate is too fuzzy to trust, or when unflattering studies seem to have gone missing. In that way of reading, one small study is a starting point, not the settled picture.
Cochrane, the network that produces careful health reviews, uses that same approach.
What a rating is not
A rating is not a promise for you. It is not a dose, a diagnosis, or a health target we invented. When a number matters, we point to the official guideline and name it. A rating describes the evidence as it stands today. Evidence moves, which is why the yearly re-check exists, and why anyone can challenge what we publish.
The cranes describe studies, and studies describe groups. Your body, your history, and your medicines are a group of one. Clear evidence is still not a personal recommendation, and a red flag is not a scolding.
Who decides
People decide. AI may help us draft and find. It does not pick the cranes.
Ratings are never for sale. No owner, investor, advertiser, or partner can buy, change, or preview one. We also do not give doses, diagnose, or set health targets of our own.
Borrow the questions
You do not need Flamel to use the checklist. The next time a claim lands in the chat, ask:
- Was it tested in people?
- How many studies were there, and how big?
- Do the results agree?
- Is the effect big enough to matter?
- Who paid for it?
---
Sources
- The Flamel Method (27 Oct 2026). Internal copy in a private repository: before publish, this link must be replaced with the public /method page (planned in the app shell's routes, not built yet). https://github.com/yggpilipinas/flamel/blob/main/docs/prd/sources/03-flamel-method/flamel-method.md
- GRADE handbook: certainty of a body of evidence. https://gradepro.org/handbook/
- Cochrane Handbook, chapter 14: assessing the certainty of evidence. https://www.cochrane.org/authors/handbooks-and-manuals/handbook/current/chapter-14
General guidance, not medical advice or a diagnosis. Talk with your doctor about your own health.
How strong is the evidence?
What the research says: The public method is Find, Weigh, Check, Show, Update. Clear evidence means several good studies agree. Some evidence means it works for some people, some of the time, or the studies are small. Red flag means there is no good evidence, the evidence goes against the claim, or the risk outweighs it. Not rated yet means we have not checked it.
What it doesn't say: A rating is not a promise for you. It is not a dose, a diagnosis, or a target we invented. Prescription-only and not-registered products get a label instead of cranes.
The Flamel Method (27 Oct 2026). Internal copy in a private repository: before publish, this link must be replaced with the public /method page (planned in the app shell's routes, not built yet).
How we rate: the Flamel MethodTry this
When a health claim lands in a group chat, ask whether it was tested in people, how many studies there were, whether they agree, whether the effect is big enough to matter, and who paid.
That counts.
Get delightful living tips directly in your email
Join freeSources
- The Flamel Method (27 Oct 2026). Internal copy in a private repository: before publish, this link must be replaced with the public /method page (planned in the app shell's routes, not built yet).
- GRADE handbook: certainty of a body of evidence
- Cochrane Handbook, chapter 14: assessing the certainty of evidence
Last reviewed by Flamel Staff on 17 Nov 2026
Flamel is not medical advice and does not diagnose. If you have symptoms or readings in the red zone, see a doctor.