Five questions to ask before you buy a supplement
A spot on the FDA list means a supplement is registered as a food, not that it treats anything. Five questions, borrowed from the way researchers judge studies, for the next bottle in the group chat.
Checked against the sources ยท Updated 17 Nov 2026
In short
- A food supplement registration is not proof the product treats disease
- A checklist for reading a supplement pitch, not a health claim, so no cranes. The regulatory point is the Philippine FDA's: food supplements are not medicines and must not be used to treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
Five questions to ask before you buy a supplement
You are halfway through breakfast when the family group chat lights up. A cousin is selling a supplement: a handsome bottle, a long list of what it supposedly helps, and a price that ends at midnight. "FDA registered po," the message says.
Before anyone pays, here is the answer you can send back. A spot on the FDA list means the product is registered as a food. It does not mean it treats anything. That comes straight from the Philippine FDA. Five questions sit behind it. They are the same questions careful researchers ask of a pile of studies, and they work in a group chat.
1. Was it tested in people?
A lot of pitches lean on studies in animals or in cells. Those can point scientists somewhere interesting. They often do not carry over to a person. A study of a lab marker in a rat is not a study of your knee pain. When the evidence does not match the human question you actually have, it counts for less.
2. How many studies, and how big?
One small study is a start, not an answer. Reviewers look at the whole set of studies on a question. Careful trials in people, without important flaws, are what they trust. A single small trial is too thin to lean on. A well-known 2005 essay by John Ioannidis argued that findings from smaller studies are easier to knock over. That essay is a way of thinking about why findings wobble, not a census of every paper ever published.
3. Do the results agree?
If one trial says yes and the next says no, the honest summary is that it is not settled. Disagreement is a reason to trust the pile less. A seller who shows you one glowing paper and stays quiet about the ones that found nothing is hoping you will not ask. Ask.
4. Is the effect big enough to matter?
A change can be real and still too small to change your week. Ask what was measured, in whom, and for how long. A lab marker moving a little is not the same as feeling better, moving more easily, or living longer. "Participants showed improvement" can mean something you would never notice.
5. Who paid?
Ioannidis makes a second point worth keeping: a finding is less likely to hold when money is riding on the hoped-for result, because bias creeps in. That is an argument about incentives, not a claim that every company-funded study is wrong. A company-funded trial can be well run. You should know that it was company-funded, and weigh it with that in mind.
And the legal one: is it even allowed to say that?
In the Philippines there is one more check, and it is the most concrete. Under Republic Act No. 9711, a food or dietary supplement is a processed food meant to supplement the diet. It is not a drug, and the FDA says it must not be used to treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Labels are supposed to carry the line "No approved therapeutic claims." Ads must include a Filipino-language statement that the product is not a medicine and must not be used as one: "Mahalagang paalala: ang [name] ay hindi gamot at hindi dapat gamiting panggamot sa anumang uri ng sakit."
When the pitch in the chat says the bottle treats something, the pitch itself is the problem, whatever is inside the bottle.
What these questions cannot do
Passing all five does not prove a product works, and a clean registration does not say the ingredient does what the ad claims. We also cannot tell you what share of supplements on the market would fail these questions. We do not have a counted share, and no percentage of that kind is used here. The Ioannidis essay is a model of how research can go wrong, not a verdict on any one paper or product.
What to do with the next bottle
- Search before you pay. Look up the brand, the product name, and the registration number at the FDA verification portal (verification.fda.gov.ph). If it is not there, that answers the evening.
- Ask the five questions in the open. If the seller's only answer is a testimonial, leave it.
- Report a misleading claim. The FDA takes reports at ereport@fda.gov.ph.
When to talk to a doctor
If you are pregnant or breastfeeding, or you are thinking of giving a supplement to a child, talk to a doctor first. The FDA's labeling rule calls for the precaution "not recommended for children, pregnant and lactating women" where it applies, depending on the product. The default is caution.
If someone suggests a supplement in place of a medicine you were prescribed, that is a conversation for your doctor before you change anything.
---
Sources
- FDA Advisory No. 2025-1552: food supplements are not medicines. https://www.fda.gov.ph/fda-advisory-no-2025-1552-public-health-warning-against-the-advertisement-promotion-marketing-and-use-of-food-dietary-supplements-for-therapeutic-purposes-and-indications/
- FDA verification portal. https://verification.fda.gov.ph/
- GRADE handbook. https://gradepro.org/handbook/
- Ioannidis JP. Why most published research findings are false. PLOS Medicine. 2005. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.0020124
General guidance, not medical advice or a diagnosis. Talk with your doctor about your own health.
How strong is the evidence?
What the research says: Under Republic Act No. 9711, a food or dietary supplement is a processed food meant to supplement the diet. Labels carry 'No approved therapeutic claims.' Ads in the Philippines must include a Filipino-language line that the product is not a medicine and must not be used as one.
What it doesn't say: We do not have a counted share of supplements that fail lab tests. No percentage of that kind is used here. A clean registration also does not say the ingredient works for the claim in the ad.
FDA Advisory No. 2025-1552: food supplements are not medicines
How we rate: the Flamel MethodTry this
- Before you pay, search the brand, the product name, and the registration number at the FDA verification portal.
- Ask the five questions on this page. If the seller can only offer a testimonial, leave it.
That counts.
See a doctor if
- You are pregnant, breastfeeding, or giving something to a child. The FDA says many of these products are not recommended in those cases.
- Someone suggests a supplement in place of a medicine you were prescribed.
Get delightful living tips directly in your email
Join freeKeep reading
Sources
- FDA Advisory No. 2025-1552: food supplements are not medicines
- FDA verification portal
- GRADE handbook
- Ioannidis JP. Why most published research findings are false. PLOS Medicine. 2005.
Last reviewed by Flamel Staff on 17 Nov 2026
Flamel is not medical advice and does not diagnose. If you have symptoms or readings in the red zone, see a doctor.